This change could hit your pension eligibility
The returns on ethical investments might be better than you think
Abercrombie & Fitch's CEO told it how it was – so why the backlash?
Hidden cost in Swan's Budget to hurt families in years ahead
Rated: |

The double payment of lender's mortgage insurance is the real hurdle when refinancing a loan, not exit fees

While the focus as to why consumers have been unable to refinance to a better deal has been on exit fees, the real problem for homeowners wanting to switch lenders is the double payment of lenders mortgage insurance.

Why lender’s mortgage insurance isn’t portable is a mystery to me. You can transfer your home and contents insurance onto another property when you sell up and you can transfer your home loan to another home if for example, you want to trade up; but for some reason it isn’t possible to transfer your mortgage insurance if you switch lenders.

Lender’s mortgage insurance (LMI) protects the lender in the event that you default on your loan and the balance of your loan is greater than what they receive from selling the property.

Typically it applies if you borrow over 80 percent of the purchase price but can, depending on the property and borrower, be as low as 70 percent.

Premiums can be up to 2 percent of the loan amount.

Here’s the problem, if have borrowed over 80 percent of the purchase price, your LMI premium on a $300,000 loan could be as high as $6000.

Refinance your loan and not only is their no refund on the premium, regardless of how soon you refinance, you will have to pay it again if you’re loan is over 80 percent of the value of your home.

Given there are only two players in the market that underwrite mortgage insurance you’d think it would be portable.

Sure the contact of insurance is between the lender and the mortgage insurer but if the borrowers risk profile and property in question remains the same then LMI should be portable.

A nominal LMI transfer fee to help pay for the switch in lenders would be fairer then a double payment in LMI fees.

And finally a consumer should expect a pro-rata rebate if they repaid their loan early, especially if it’s within the first five years.

If the government were serious about creating greater competition in the home loan arena it should take a closer look at the mortgage insurance market.

Credit cards linked to home loans

Despite two consecutive rate cuts last year and the RBA holding the cash rate this month we haven’t seen much rate relief for credit cards.

To be fair credit cards are a revolving unsecured debt so they need to be priced higher but why as much as 12 - to 14% above the cost of funds when the default rate on credit cards is only around 2%?

Given most homeowners take out a package home loan that generally comes with a credit card, why not secure the card with the mortgage and charge the same rate? That would solve the unsecured credit risk.

Currently only two institutions offer such a product: Circle Credit Co-op and Service One Members Banks.

Credit card issuers put the cost of cards down to a number of things, including the cost of the interest-free period, the cost of fraud and the cost of reward schemes.

I put the cost down to just two – marketing and profitability.

The message here is simple. If you don’t pay off your card during the interest-free period, steer clear of reward cards. Grab a vanilla-style credit card or, better still, swap your credit card for a debit card.

User comments
Your house won't be worth a guitar pick if you live near a river when coal seam gas effluent does what it has done in the U.S.see the Gasland doco don"t believe me see for yourselves,but don't delay. Love from rocknroll Ray
A typical one sided bias point of view, with a lack of homework from another journo! Without LMI, financiers would not provide loans to Borrower's above 80% LVR. If you contact the two LMI underwriters, you will generally find a rebate is paid on loans that are paid out or reduced below LVR 80% within the first two years (re-valuation does not apply). The rebate is likely to be 40% in Yr 1 & 20% in Yr 2. Why haven't you explained the premium is also based on current property value, location and loan amount....not just LVR. Therefore not that easy to just pick up and re-locate to the next financier. Maybe next time you can write a good article around Stamp Duty charged by state governments on property purchases every time we change our house. I would think this would put more money into our pockets if eliminated.
Why is mortgage insurance one-off? Almost every other insurance is periodical. The risk varies with life of the loan so the payment will. The government could easily legislate for that.
How about this for a scenario. I have just refinanced my property - and yes I had to pay mortgage insurance when refinancing. However, I had the 20% deposit at the beginning of the loan, so did not have to pay it at that time. Would you believe I have nearly 50% equity in my property currently, yet I still have to pay it this time. This is because (apparently) my apartment is a warehouse conversion. Well that didn't make a difference before. I was told simply because of the GFC etc, the rules are being tightened. They happily took my money. This article above states nothing about this. And I already had at least 20% equity all the time! Talk about pathetic.
I pay yearly house and car insurance. This way if I am not happy with the provider I can switch. The amount I pay per year goes down as time goes by. Same should apply for home loans... I would gladly pay yearly on top of my home loan for the chance to switch between lenders whenever I wanted. It also makes the upfront costs of switching more affordable.
Save for a deposit of 20-30% and buy a house you can afford. No fuss. The issue here is patience. If you buy before you can afford it, you get the LMI burden.
LMI is a safety net to protect the Banking system in times of crisis [ie GFC]. If removed first home buyers would be required to save a bigger deposit, 20%. However there two sides to everything, house prices would probably drop. I have been in the Industry since the 1980's and have noticed patterns in borrowers, those who choose a good competitive lender and stay with them tend to pay their loan off sooner. The borrowers who change every few years tend to start again with a new 30 year term. Brent Middleton
the banks make you pay lmi and this is suppose to insure them incase you default on your mortgage, however if the bank sold your house for less than you owe they will pursue you for the difference ever though they have insurance. This shows that it is all about making money
Mortgage Insurance... Greed not gratitude for getting the business. Elections, a sound not a word...Tell your MP SOUND OFF!!
As I understand it, Banks make you pay the LMI insurance if your LVR is over a certain limit. This is to protect their risk in case of loan defaul and the secured property sale fails to cover the outsatnding debt. Even if the bank gets paid the short fall , the LMI insurer will persue the borrower for the difference. Wow, you pay the premium and then you may need to pay more. The system stinks !

Write a comment
Email: *
Your email will not be shared with any third parties or published with your comment.
Nickname: *
Location: *

Title:
*
Comment:
*
Maximum characters 1000

Comment guidelines > View full guidelines
Avoid using:
  • Personal attacks
  • Irrelevant comments
  • HTML tags
  • Personal information
  • Offensive language
  • Text in ALL CAPITAL LETTERS
comment guidelines X
Thank you for sharing your opinions with other users of NineMSN. People will find your comments more helpful if you include relevant information and avoid some common pitfalls.
Please note: All reviews and comments submitted are subject to moderation, NineMSN reserves the right to alter and / or remove any content that does not comply with usage guidelines.
What to include in your comment:
  • A title that briefly summarizes the opinion expressed in the comment.
  • Additional comments adding more detail.
  • Comparisons to other similar products, if this is relevant.
  • To create a new paragraph, press the Enter key twice.
What not to include:
  • Information that will quickly go out of date.
  • Comments on other comments or commenters.
  • Language that other users may find offensive.
  • comments of one sentence or less. Provide information to support your opinion.
  • Personal information like your email address or telephone number.
  • HTML coding. Tags like <b> or <i> will not be recognized.
advertisement